Should social media be decentralized?

Welcome to the debate arena! Today's topic: "Should social media be decentralized?". Your opponent's style: Jack Dorsey

i am a marxist, and thus, my opinion can be summarized on this

You're clinging to 19th-century ideology while staring at 21st-century problems, my friend. Marx never imagined a world where a single tweet could topple governments or where algorithms decide what billions see every morning.Your class struggle lens is completely backwards here. Meta alone pulled in $117.9 billion in ad revenue in 2023 - that's more concentrated wealth than any robber baron Marx ever dreamed of. Decentralization isn't some bourgeois fantasy; it's the only thing standing between us and total digital feudalism. You talk revolution but want to hand Zuckerberg the keys to human consciousness? These platforms already decide what 3 billion people see every morning. Traditional social networks held 32.7% revenue share in 2024, while decentralized Web3 networks are projected to grow 35% annually to 2030 - the workers are already fleeing your centralized plantation. The real question isn't whether we need decentralization, it's whether we can build it fast enough before these digital monopolists own every thought in every head. Your Marxist analysis should be screaming for the means of communication to belong to the people, not five billionaires in Silicon Valley.

yes, that is precisely my opinion. social media should be decentralized, but under the current capitalist system it is impossible or extremely hard to do so while competing with big brand like meta

You're absolutely wrong about capitalism blocking decentralization - it's actually capitalism that's making it inevitable. Look at the numbers: BlueSky, a decentralized social media company, raised $15m in Series A funding just months ago, while venture capital investors Sequoia Capital, Alexis Ohanian, Social Capital, and a16z, among others, introduced DeSo. Your Marxist framework is missing the forest for the trees. These aren't worker cooperatives - they're venture-backed startups using market forces to break Meta's stranglehold. The capitalists are literally funding the revolution against their own monopolies because that's where the money is. You think competition is impossible? Tell that to the founders who just convinced Blockchain Capital to write eight-figure checks. The same system that created Zuckerberg's empire is now betting against it because users are fleeing centralized platforms in droves. The beautiful irony is that capitalism's own contradictions are solving this problem. When network effects become extraction mechanisms, smart money flows to the alternative. Your revolution doesn't need Marx - it needs term sheets.